
In general, I think that men and women aren’t really all that different and that the “men are from Mars, women are from Venus” arguments are pretty silly. It my experience, it’s often used as a cop-out to avoid actually learning how to communicate with your significant other.
That being said…I swear my husband is from a different planet.
Let me explain:
Over the past few weeks and and while seeing many family and friends at holiday get-togethers, a significant number of people have been commenting that Tom has lost weight. I personally didn’t see it at all and thought these people needed their eyes checked…until Tom told me he has lost over fifteen pounds since our wedding day.
Ummmm…what?!
My gut reaction was panic—Why have you lost weight?! Are you okay? How is this possible when I serve you enough food to feed an average family of four?!
My hysteria was calmed when we realized what was actually causing this change:
- He wasn’t eating Jimmy John’s for lunch every day
- He’s been running more–either with me or while choosing to play more basketball over lunch
Being that I sensed this change bothered him, we talked about it. In doing so, I learned that he had stopped adding mass gainer to his protein every day and that he thought he needed to add it back in. Somewhat confused, I asked for clarity on what exactly “mass gainer” actually was. His response? It’s a powder that adds significant calories and carbs to your protein.
My response? WHY IN THE WORLD WOULD YOU WANT TO CONSUME A CRAP TON OF CALORIES AND CARBS THAT YOU CAN’T EVEN TASTE? If you’re consuming the same amount of calories and carbs that are in two ginormous slices of chocolate cake…why would you not choose to eat the cake?! The cake has taste! The cake has flavor! The cake has CHOCOLATE.

On the flip side, I personally literally not imagine a world where I would consume calories knowing I couldn’t taste and savor them. If I am knowingly consuming the same amount of calories and carbohydrates as I could find in one of my favorite desserts I would go straight for the killer brownies at Byerly’s and call it a day.

Hence, my conclusion that my husband is from a different planet.
Understanding that my pre-diabetes (and thus our cooking) usually limits the amounts of carbohydrates and sugar we’re consuming, I can understand why Tom was seeking out another source for these nasty buggers. But his desire for more calories got me thinking–especially since we don’t try to limit our calories in any way; we just try make sure most of them are coming from nutrient-dense sources like nuts or fruit.
Being that it’s the season of baking, I got to brainstorming about how I could create a satisfying Christmas treat that was diabetic-friendly AND could also pack a protein punch to help continue to supplement Tom’s desire to gain back the weight he’s lost. And if I could find a way to sneak in some cardamom? Well, that would be a classic Michael Scott “win/win/win” situation.
So…where’s the compromise?
Here’s our (win/win/win) answer:
- Replace traditional all-purpose flour with almond flour–a high protein, low-carbohydrate (and gluten-free!) substitution
- Utilize applesauce to sweeten the cookies instead of white & brown sugar
- Pair a small amount of traditional molasses with pure maple syrup to maintain the color and richness of traditional gingerbread cookies
- Use a heavy amount of spices (including cardamom!) to ensure that the cookies deliver on the classic gingerbread flavors…and make Scandinavians everywhere jump for joy
| First Christmas Cookies |
Serves: Makes 3 dozen cookies–so 9 Tom’s or 36 Alaina’s
Ingredients Needed:
- 1 lb. finely ground almond flour (~3.8 cups)
- Almond flour is flour made out of (you guessed it) finely ground almonds–which is awesome, but also means it can be expensive. You can find sales on Bob’s (pictured below) that is sold in 1 lb. bags for about $10, or Costco sells a 3 lb. bag for $22 (~$7.33/lb)
- 2 tsp. baking soda
- 2 tsp. ground cinnamon
- 1 tsp. ground ginger
- 1 tsp. ground allspice
- 1/2 tsp. ground cloves
- 1/4 tsp. ground nutmeg
- 1/4 tsp. cardamom
- 1 stick butter, melted
- You want salted butter here, NOT unsalted
- 1/2 cup no-sugar-added applesauce
- Check your ingredients–it should just say “apples, water”!
- 1/4 cup unsulphured dark molasses
- Also called “full”, “robust”, or “second” molasses–this is key to obtaining the classic gingerbread flavor (avoid “light” or “blackstrap” molasses)
- 2 tbsp. pure maple syrup
- Like with the meatloaf, no fake corn syrup “maple” syrup here–you want the real deal
- 1 large egg
- Flour, for dusting work surface
- I use all-purpose flour since it’s what I keep on-hand, but you can also use any gluten-free baking flour to keep the recipe 100% gluten free
- For another gluten-free note, make sure you are using pure maple syrup and real molasses–this is critical as most of the non-pure/real versions sub-in other ingredients that could have gluten in them
Directions:
First up, prep your dry ingredients…
- Measure out all dry ingredients (flour, soda, & spices) into a large bowl
- Whisk dry ingredients thoroughly
- This is key to ensuring that the cookies bake properly. Normally you would sift your dry ingredients, but this is made difficult with the slightly grainier texture of almond flour
- Set aside
Now get you wet ingredients mixed…
- In a large mixing bowl, mix melted butter, applesauce, molasses, maple syrup, and egg using a whisk or mixer until well combined
Now you’re ready to combine your dry and wet mixes…
- Using a spoon (do NOT use a mixer–it will make the dough too runny) gradually stir the flour mixture into the wet mixture
The tough part is next…you have be PATIENT….
- Separate your dough in half, form each half into a flat disc-shape, and wrap each disc in plastic wrap
- If you have not discovered “Stretch Tite” plastic wrap yet you are in for a life-changing moment. I will not even touch other plastic wrap–it just makes me frustrated when it breaks and sticks to itself! This stuff is. the. best.
- Refrigerate dough for at least three hours
- You can refrigerate for up to two days, you will just have to let it thaw out slightly longer when you’re ready to work with it
Three (or more) hours have gone by…now you’re ready to bake!
- Preheat your oven to 325 degrees F
- Remove your first dough “disc” from the fridge and let it thaw on the counter while you prepare you working surface (~5-10 minutes)
- Lightly dust your working surface with flour and brush your rolling pin with some as well
- This is a sticky dough–this is important!
- Unwrap your dough (saving plastic wrap!) and set it in the middle of your working surface and sprinkle a bit more flour on top before rolling out to be about 1/8 inch (or so) thick
- Cut out as many cookies as possible and transfer to cookie sheet–positioning them about 1 inch or so apart (they don’t spread–so don’t worry about that!
- Take remaining scraps, re-combine into another disc, and then re-wrap in plastic wrap and place in fridge
- It is key that this dough stays cold so that you can work with it AND so it bakes evenly
- Remove second disc from fridge and repeats steps above–placing dough back in fridge after you’ve rolled it out and cut out enough cookies to fill your first cookie sheet
- Bake cookies in oven for 12 minutes on a silpat or ungreased cookie sheet–setting timer for halfway through (6 minutes) to rotate cookies 180 degrees to ensure even baking
- Once 12 minutes have passed, remove cookies from oven and let cool on cookie sheet for 2 minutes
- Once 2 minutes have passed, carefully transfer cookies to wire cooling rack
- Almond flour cookies are notoriously fragile/crumbly until they’ve fully cooled–be extra careful!
- Repeat above steps until all cookies have baked and are cooling
- Leave cookies on wire cooling rack for at least 8 hours (overnight works well!) to ensure they have full cooled and dried (do not stack them when cooling)
- Once 8 hours have passed, package them in an airtight container or ziploc bag, ensuring that you don’t stack more than two high in the container to avoid soggy cookies
You’ve baked your cookies! Congratulations! Now what?
- These cookies are delicious plain, but since it is Christmastime, a little icing can be super fun–plus the little bit of sweetness and vanilla balances out the spice of this cookie in the most INSANELY DELECTABLE way
- You can use any store-bought or homemade icing, but I recommend using homemade to avoid the weird ingredients that can be found in store-bought. My favorite? Alton Brown’s Royal Icing recipe is easy, uses ingredients you already have on hand, and maintains a slight softness when it dries that keeps you from breaking a tooth as you bite into your favorite cookie!
- Once you have the icing, just pop it in a freezer-thickness zip-top bag witha snipped corner and decorate to your heart’s content…or at least to the best of your ability…which (as you can see below) is very lacking for me personally…
Okay, so I know what you’re thinking…and I know these cookies are putzy. There’s a few extra steps that seem kinda silly and take a tiny bit of extra time, but I’m telling you it’s so, so worth it. And really, I promise, it’s no more work than having to roll eight million peanut butter balls in sugar and then unwrap eight million chocolate kisses to put in them. We all make those cookies every year…this isn’t any different!
So why is the little bit of extra effort worth it? Let me the count the ways…
- These cookies have the perfect consistency
- They’re chewy on the inside, but they have crisp, smooth outside that’s perfect for decorating
- These cookies have the perfect spice balance
- These cookies are like a perfectly harmonious chorus of spices singing the same Christmas carol and there’s no loud soprano (like cinnamon or ginger) overpowering the soulful altos (cloves & cardamom) that make the tune so rich
- These cookies are diabetic-friendly AND gluten-free friendly
- Did I mention there’s only 4 carbohydrates and 3 sugars per cookie?
- These cookies are PACKED with protein and fill you up (or at least fill me up!) with just one cookie
- Each 100 calorie cookie has a whopping 3 grams of protein
So while all of the above are reasons why these cookies are fantastic, these cookies are also wonderful to me and Tom because they’re so distinctively us. They’re a balance of what we both want in the food we eat and the food we want to feed our family one day–which makes them incredibly special.
In fact, above all that’s my favorite thing about these cookies: they’re ours. They’ll be the cookies we bring to cookie exchanges. They’ll be the cookies we make every year and decorate for our families. They’ll be the cookies we set out for Santa…and then secretly devour while the kiddos are sleeping. They’ll be our new tradition.
Because that’s the thing they don’t really talk enough about when you do pre-marital counseling…figuring out how to balance traditions when you get married is hard. It can so easily spiral into a swirl of “my family does this“, “my church has this“, “my tradition is this” instead of choosing to do what’s best for your new family unit: you and your spouse.

So while these cookies won’t make all the stressors of holidays disappear or make Tom magically gain weight (even though I would prefer he just eat ten cookies instead of drinking scary powder made from who-knows-what), they are a true compromise and a true reflection of our very distinctive personalities. To put it simply, they’re a win-win-win.
Here’s to making many more culinary compromises…all in the name of love.
xoxo,
alaina




















